Per Nergård (MVP)
+1
Sep 14, 2012
visibility 4825
star star star star star
(1 votes)

CMS5 to CMS6 upgrade. XForm validation

When upgrading a customer site from CMS5 to 6 we got some errors regarding XForms.

We got errors reporting of forms containing fields with names longer than 75 characters as well as forms with fields having duplicate names.

I wasn’t completely surprised that we got errors since my experience of upgrades of forms hasn’t been the best.

If your site isn’t migrated from 4.X you shouldn’t get any of these errors because EPiServer has added a lot of validation regarding forms starting from CMS5.

To avoid having to run the upgrade several times and so I next time can do a check for XForm problems in advance I  did a small program that goes through all forms checking for the type of errors we got in this particular case.

The program just prints out a table with the following information

Form-GUID, Form-name,Type of error found, PageId, Key

The PageId column contains a id to a page that uses the current form (it only contains one pageid even if the form is used on more pages), the key column contains the name of the offending XForm field if the error is a duplicate field.

To use it just download the zip file and drop the .aspx and .cs in your sites root folder and browse to it. If you later want to validate a specific form you can to by adding ?guid= to the url.

If you get many forms that aren’t used on any page it can be a bit of a pain locating them through the XForm UI, at least if you have a lot of forms. But there is a quick shortcut if you have the GUID.

Just add your site name, edit ui path and the GUID to the Url below and you will get straight into editing of the form.

http://yoursite.com/youreditpath/edit/XFormEdit.aspx?pageId=&parentId=&formid=fa8e1d3e-796c-426b-931a-a62bf51b9563&selectedFormName=/

 

* Update *

Added Henrik Stabergs suggestion to check for fields with id aswell. Wasn’t able to update the code section so the updated files can be downloaded from here

.

Sep 14, 2012

Comments

Sep 26, 2012 09:06 AM

Hi Per,
Thanks for a nice tool to validate xForms before upgrading!

I also got errors when upgrading xForms with input fields namned "id", "Id" och "ID".
More information in Tobias Nilssons article: http://world.episerver.com/Blogs/Tobias-Nilsson/Dates/2010/11/XForm-reserved-names-for-input-fields/

A check for this condition can easily be added to the method DoAllChecks(XForm xf) {...}

Per Nergård (MVP)
Per Nergård (MVP) Sep 26, 2012 09:40 AM

Thanks for the input.

I've added the "id" check to the program but I have problem uploading it to the Code section.

error Please login to comment.
Latest blogs
You’re not headless. You’re hybrid — and that’s the CMS 12 default.

For CMS 12 / Commerce teams with a React (or similar) storefront who keep hearing “just go headless” or “just move to Graph.” This is Part 1 of Fin...

Hanskumar Tripathi | Aug 13, 2026

Stott Security for Optimizely SaaS CMS

Introduction Stott Security  has been helping developers and editors manage Content Security Policies and security headers on  Optimizely PaaS CMS...

Mark Stott | Aug 13, 2026

Optimizely XML Resource Builder: A Visual Studio Extension for Language Resource Files

Anyone who has worked on a larger Optimizely solution will know the feeling. You add or update a page type, block type, or shared base class,

Adnan Zameer | Aug 13, 2026 |

Optimizely SaaS CMS Management API: The Write Side of Headless

Everything I’ve written in this series so far has been about reading content — Optimizely Graph, webhooks, ISR, caching layers. But at some point y...

Kiran Patil | Aug 12, 2026 |